‹ All posts

The busiest routes: club pairs that share the most players

Some pairs of clubs keep swapping footballers for decades, and they are rarely the pairs anyone would guess.

By ·

At a glanceTop 10 by shared players
  1. Fiorentina & Genoa40
  2. Fiorentina & Juventus36
  3. Parma & Sampdoria35
  4. Genoa & Milan34
  5. Atalanta & Cagliari33
  6. Getafe & Valencia27
  7. Fulham & Tottenham Hotspur25
  8. Getafe & Real Valladolid25
  9. Aston Villa & Everton23
  10. Aston Villa & Liverpool22

Take any two clubs in the same league and count the players who have appeared in it for both. Most pairs come out in single figures. A small number keep turning up the same answer over and over, because the clubs sell, loan and re-sign to each other as a matter of routine. This post ranks those pairs, five per league across England, Spain, Italy and Germany.

The busiest route of all runs between Florence and Genoa. Fiorentina and Genoa have 40 players in common in Serie A since 2000/01, and Serie A dominates the top of the table so heavily that its fifth-placed pair, Atalanta and Cagliari on 33, beats the leading pair in every other league. In England the busiest route is Fulham and Tottenham, with 25 shared players, and in Spain it is Getafe and Valencia on 27.

Big rivalries are almost absent. None of England's five busiest pairs is a local derby, and the clubs that feature most often are the ones that act as buyers and sellers to everyone. The table counts any player with league games for both clubs, in either order and with any gap between, loans included.

Club pairs with the most players in common, five per league
#PairShared players
1Fiorentina & GenoaLeague: Serie A40
2Fiorentina & JuventusLeague: Serie A36
3Parma & SampdoriaLeague: Serie A35
4Genoa & MilanLeague: Serie A34
5Atalanta & CagliariLeague: Serie A33
6Getafe & ValenciaLeague: La Liga27
7Fulham & Tottenham HotspurLeague: Premier League25
8Getafe & Real ValladolidLeague: La Liga25
9Aston Villa & EvertonLeague: Premier League23
10Aston Villa & LiverpoolLeague: Premier League22
11Liverpool & West Ham UnitedLeague: Premier League21
12Atlético Madrid & MallorcaLeague: La Liga21
13Getafe & LevanteLeague: La Liga21
14Levante & ValenciaLeague: La Liga21
15Mainz 05 & Schalke 04League: Bundesliga21
16Arsenal & West Ham UnitedLeague: Premier League; level on 19: Chelsea & Manchester City, Newcastle United & Tottenham Hotspur19
17Borussia Dortmund & StuttgartLeague: Bundesliga17
18Schalke 04 & StuttgartLeague: Bundesliga17
19Eintracht Frankfurt & Schalke 04League: Bundesliga16
20Augsburg & Hertha BSCLeague: Bundesliga; level on 15: Augsburg & Wolfsburg, Bayer Leverkusen & Mainz 05, Eintracht Frankfurt & Wolfsburg, Köln & Wolfsburg, Nürnberg & Wolfsburg, Stuttgart & Wolfsburg15
Seasons 1992/93 in England, 2000/01 elsewhere to 2025/26

Five pairs per league, because Serie A's pairs would otherwise take all twenty rows. Pairs level with a league's fifth row are named in its note. Only finished seasons count, so a player whose second club came this season is not yet included.

Forty players between Florence and Genoa

Fiorentina–Genoa is not a rivalry and the clubs are not neighbours, yet 40 players have league games for both since 2000/01. Fiorentina was the first club for 26 of them and Genoa for 14, so the main current runs from Florence towards the Ligurian coast. Several of the names are players Fiorentina had finished with: Sébastien Frey played 175 games in goal for Fiorentina and then 74 for Genoa, and Dario Dainelli and Alessandro Gamberini made the same trip in defence.

The traffic is not all one way. Christian Kouamé started at Genoa and has played 111 Serie A games for Fiorentina since 2019/20. Albert Guðmundsson went the same direction in 2024/25 after three seasons at Genoa. Alberto Gilardino went from Fiorentina to Genoa and then back again, and so did Juan Manuel Vargas.

Milan Badelj has the most games for the pair, 130 for Fiorentina and 120 for Genoa. At the other end, Davide Brivio counts with three league appearances in total, and Salvatore Sirigu is on the list for a single Fiorentina game after 37 for Genoa. The count treats every crossing the same, so a pair can climb on short loans as easily as on long careers, and this one has plenty of both.

Fiorentina appears again in second place, with 36 players shared with Juventus, and Genoa is back in fourth with Milan on 34, so the two clubs at the top each feature twice in Serie A's five busiest pairs.

Fulham and Tottenham, mostly westward

England's busiest pair has 25 players, and 17 of them were at Tottenham first. That suits Fulham's long-standing role as a club that buys experienced players from bigger ones. Simon Davies played 121 league games for Spurs and then 137 for Fulham. Danny Murphy, Bobby Zamora, Paul Konchesky and Kasey Keller all went from White Hart Lane to Craven Cottage, as did Dimitar Berbatov after his time at Manchester United.

The players who went the other way tend to be the more valuable ones. Mousa Dembélé played 62 games for Fulham and then 181 for Tottenham, the most for the pair by anyone. Steed Malbranque made the same move after 172 games at Fulham, and João Palhinha joined Spurs for 2025/26 after two Fulham seasons. Clint Dempsey went to Tottenham for a season and then came back to Fulham.

Ryan Sessegnon has made the trip twice, Fulham to Spurs and back, returning to Fulham in 2024/25. Lewis Holtby, a Tottenham loanee at Fulham in 2013/14, is the only player in this post who counts towards the busiest pair in two different leagues: he also played for both Mainz 05 and Schalke 04.

Behind Fulham and Spurs come Aston Villa and Everton on 23, Aston Villa and Liverpool on 22 and Liverpool and West Ham on 21. Arsenal and West Ham share 19, level with Chelsea and Manchester City and with Newcastle and Tottenham.

Getafe as Valencia's waiting room

La Liga's leading pair is a lopsided one. Getafe and Valencia share 27 players, and Valencia was the first club for 19 of them. Several were young Valencia players sent to Getafe to play, or senior players moved on when Valencia no longer needed them. Miku, Miguel Ángel Moyá and Omar Alderete were all at Valencia first and played most of their games for the pair at Getafe.

Getafe also works as a stepping stone in the other direction. Dani Parejo played 64 league games at Getafe and then 282 for Valencia, the most for the pair. Roberto Soldado, Raúl Albiol and Hugo Duro all went to Valencia after starting at Getafe, and Duro has 164 Valencia games since 2021/22. Jaime Gavilán had four separate spells across the two clubs, and Alexis and Paco Alcácer three each.

Getafe sits in three of La Liga's five busiest pairs, with Real Valladolid (25) and Levante (21) as well as Valencia. Levante and Valencia share 21 too, and Atlético Madrid and Mallorca make up the fifth row. In the Bundesliga the leading pair is Mainz 05 and Schalke 04 on 21, and Schalke features in three of the league's four busiest routes.

Why some clubs keep trading

The pairs at the top share a shape. One club tends to be the seller and the other the buyer, and the relationship survives changes of coach, owner and sporting director because it suits both. Fulham took on Tottenham's surplus, Getafe took on Valencia's, and both sent the occasional player back the other way.

Serie A's numbers are higher across the board, and loans explain much of it. Italian clubs have long moved players between each other on temporary deals, buy-back clauses and shared ownership, so the same footballer can count for a pair after a few months at the second club. Parma and Sampdoria share 35 players, a total no English pair approaches.

Proximity matters less than you might expect. Fiorentina and Genoa are a long way apart, as are Getafe and Valencia, and the busiest English pair is two London clubs whose meetings nobody treats as a derby. The derbies covered in the site's rivalry posts are mostly short lists, because those are the routes clubs prefer not to use.

For Career Path, these routes are worth knowing because they repeat. A career that shows Valencia followed by Getafe, or Tottenham followed by Fulham, is one of dozens with the same two stops.

The short version

Fiorentina and Genoa share 40 Serie A players without ever being rivals. The busiest routes are habits between a seller and a buyer, not derbies.