Booked most often: yellow cards per 90 minutes
Forget the career totals. This is about how quickly a player found his way into the referee's notebook.
By Gareth Lloyd ·
- Jaime MataGetafe0.52
- Pablo GarcíaOsasuna0.51
- RecioMálaga0.48
- Alberto BotíaSporting Gijón0.47
- Marcelo RomeroMálaga0.47
- David ThompsonBlackburn Rovers0.46
- Víctor SánchezEspanyol0.46
- Carlos DiogoReal Zaragoza0.46
- David AlbeldaValencia0.46
- Stefano SturaroGenoa0.46
A long career piles up bookings almost by default. A holding midfielder who plays 400 league games will collect a large number of yellow cards even if he is booked no more often than average, which is why the all-time totals mostly reward durability. The more revealing question is how often a player was cautioned for the time he spent on the pitch, and that is what this table measures: league yellow cards for every 90 minutes played, across the four biggest leagues.
On that measure the leaders are not the names the totals would suggest. The top spot belongs to Jaime Mata, a Getafe striker, by the narrowest of margins over Pablo García, the Uruguayan midfielder whose Osasuna years earned him a reputation. Fourteen of the twenty rows come from La Liga. The Premier League supplies two, Serie A four and the Bundesliga none at all, though Germany's leader misses the cut by a fraction.
Each row needs at least 9,000 minutes in one league, the equivalent of a hundred full matches. That keeps out players who were booked twice in a short cameo career. The note column gives the cards, the minutes and how many minutes passed, on average, between bookings.
| # | Player | Per 90 | Yellows, minutes, league | Main clubs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jaime Mata2018/19–2024/25Yellows, minutes, league: 62 in 10,768 minutes, one every 174; La Liga | 0.52 | 62 in 10,768 minutes, one every 174; La Liga | Getafe, Las Palmas |
| 2 | Pablo García2002/03–2007/08Yellows, minutes, league: 61 in 10,670 minutes, one every 175; La Liga | 0.51 | 61 in 10,670 minutes, one every 175; La Liga | Osasuna, Real Madrid, Real Murcia |
| 3 | Recio2010/11–2020/21Yellows, minutes, league: 88 in 16,639 minutes, one every 189; La Liga | 0.48 | 88 in 16,639 minutes, one every 189; La Liga | Málaga, Granada, Leganés |
| 4 | Alberto Botía2008/09–2013/14Yellows, minutes, league: 63 in 11,962 minutes, one every 190; La Liga | 0.47 | 63 in 11,962 minutes, one every 190; La Liga | Sporting Gijón, Elche, Sevilla |
| 5 | Marcelo Romero2001/02–2005/06Yellows, minutes, league: 49 in 9,415 minutes, one every 192; La Liga | 0.47 | 49 in 9,415 minutes, one every 192; La Liga | Málaga |
| 6 | David Thompson1996/97–2006/07Yellows, minutes, league: 51 in 9,873 minutes, one every 194; Premier League | 0.46 | 51 in 9,873 minutes, one every 194; Premier League | Blackburn Rovers, Liverpool, Coventry City |
| 7 | Víctor Sánchez2007/08–2019/20Yellows, minutes, league: 116 in 22,681 minutes, one every 196; La Liga | 0.46 | 116 in 22,681 minutes, one every 196; La Liga | Espanyol, Getafe, Xerez |
| 8 | Carlos Diogo2005/06–2010/11Yellows, minutes, league: 51 in 10,014 minutes, one every 196; La Liga | 0.46 | 51 in 10,014 minutes, one every 196; La Liga | Real Zaragoza, Real Madrid |
| 9 | David Albelda2000/01–2012/13Yellows, minutes, league: 129 in 25,379 minutes, one every 197; La Liga | 0.46 | 129 in 25,379 minutes, one every 197; La Liga | Valencia |
| 10 | Stefano Sturaro2013/14–2021/22Yellows, minutes, league: 49 in 9,660 minutes, one every 197; Serie A | 0.46 | 49 in 9,660 minutes, one every 197; Serie A | Genoa, Juventus, Hellas Verona |
| 11 | Rubén Pérez2009/10–2019/20Yellows, minutes, league: 104 in 20,898 minutes, one every 201; La Liga | 0.45 | 104 in 20,898 minutes, one every 201; La Liga | Leganés, Granada, Deportivo La Coruña |
| 12 | Mario Balotelli2007/08–2024/25Yellows, minutes, league: 45 in 9,057 minutes, one every 201; Serie A | 0.45 | 45 in 9,057 minutes, one every 201; Serie A | Milan, Inter, Brescia |
| 13 | José Manuel Casado2007/08–2014/15Yellows, minutes, league: 46 in 9,338 minutes, one every 203; La Liga | 0.44 | 46 in 9,338 minutes, one every 203; La Liga | Rayo Vallecano, Xerez, Recreativo Huelva |
| 14 | Daniele Conti2004/05–2014/15Yellows, minutes, league: 133 in 27,040 minutes, one every 203; Serie A | 0.44 | 133 in 27,040 minutes, one every 203; Serie A | Cagliari |
| 15 | Fernando Amorebieta2005/06–2016/17Yellows, minutes, league: 89 in 18,179 minutes, one every 204; La Liga | 0.44 | 89 in 18,179 minutes, one every 204; La Liga | Athletic Club, Sporting Gijón |
| 16 | Deco2004/05–2007/08Yellows, minutes, league: 44 in 9,014 minutes, one every 205; La Liga | 0.44 | 44 in 9,014 minutes, one every 205; La Liga | Barcelona |
| 17 | Nicolò Zaniolo2018/19–2025/26Yellows, minutes, league: 44 in 9,086 minutes, one every 206; Serie A | 0.44 | 44 in 9,086 minutes, one every 206; Serie A | Roma, Udinese, Atalanta |
| 18 | Cheick Tioté2010/11–2015/16Yellows, minutes, league: 52 in 10,974 minutes, one every 211; Premier League | 0.43 | 52 in 10,974 minutes, one every 211; Premier League | Newcastle United |
| 19 | Álex Gálvez2011/12–2018/19Yellows, minutes, league: 48 in 10,159 minutes, one every 212; La Liga | 0.43 | 48 in 10,159 minutes, one every 212; La Liga | Rayo Vallecano, Eibar, Las Palmas |
| 20 | Rubén Alcaraz2018/19–2023/24Yellows, minutes, league: 63 in 13,350 minutes, one every 212; La Liga | 0.42 | 63 in 13,350 minutes, one every 212; La Liga | Real Valladolid, Cádiz |
| Seasons 1996/97 in England, 2000/01 elsewhere to 2025/26 | ||||
A player is ranked separately in each league where he reached 9,000 minutes. Two bookings in one match that end in a dismissal are recorded as a red, not as two yellows.
Mata and Pablo García, a near dead heat
Mata's rate is 0.518 yellows per 90 and García's is 0.515, so the table's rounding to 0.52 and 0.51 makes the gap look bigger than it is. In practice it is one minute: Mata was booked every 174 minutes and García every 175. Mata picked up 62 cautions in 10,768 minutes, García 61 in 10,670.
How they got there was very different. García earned his rate as a starter. His three Osasuna seasons from 2002/03 brought 9, 14 and 17 yellows, the last of those in 2,441 minutes, and he added ten in 1,380 minutes at Real Madrid in 2005/06. Five red cards came on top.
Mata's figure leans on the end of his career, when he was mostly coming off the bench. In 2022/23 he played 437 minutes for Getafe and was booked five times. At Las Palmas in 2024/25 he managed 656 minutes and nine bookings, one every 73 minutes. Short appearances late in a game, chasing a result or closing one out, are a quick way to collect cards, and a striker pressing defenders is more exposed to it than people expect.
Behind them come Recio at 0.48, Alberto Botía and Marcelo Romero at 0.47, and Víctor Sánchez at 0.46, whose 116 bookings over 22,681 minutes make his one of the steadier high rates in the table.
Thompson, Tioté and Cattermole in England
Lee Cattermole is the name most English fans would expect to lead, and the correction for two-yellow dismissals has moved him down. On the official count of 88 Premier League yellows in 19,720 minutes he was booked every 224 minutes, a rate of 0.40. That is third in England and outside the top twenty overall.
The Premier League's quickest is David Thompson, at 0.46, booked 51 times in 9,873 minutes for one card every 194. His busiest spell came at Coventry City in 2000/01, eleven yellows in 1,860 minutes, and he had collected nine at Liverpool in 1999/00. He ranks sixth in the whole table.
Cheick Tioté is the other Premier League row, eighteenth overall with 0.43. All 52 of his bookings came for Newcastle United, 14 of them in his first season, 2010/11, when he played 2,308 minutes.
Cattermole still has by far the most bookings of the three. His case shows how the rate and the total measure different things: he played twice as many minutes as Thompson, and a high count spread over a long career gives a lower rate than a short one concentrated into fewer games. His sharpest single season was 2014/15, fourteen yellows for Sunderland in 2,357 minutes.
Sturaro, Balotelli and Conti in Italy
Serie A's four rows cover very different players. Stefano Sturaro leads them at 0.46, booked 49 times in 9,660 minutes across Genoa, Juventus and Hellas Verona. His final full season, 2021/22 at Genoa, brought 12 bookings in 1,766 minutes.
Mario Balotelli is second in Italy at 0.45 and clears the minimum by only 57 minutes, with 45 yellows in 9,057. A forward who spent much of his Serie A career at Inter and Milan, he collected his cards in every spell, including two in 62 minutes for Genoa in 2024/25.
Daniele Conti is the opposite kind of entry. His 0.44 comes from 27,040 minutes, the largest base in the table, all of it for Cagliari between 2004/05 and 2014/15. That works out at one booking every 203 minutes for eleven seasons, never fewer than nine in a season, and his 133 cautions are the most of anyone in the twenty.
Nicolò Zaniolo completes the Italian set at 0.44, another attacking player, which makes Serie A the league where attacking players are most visible near the top. Leandro Paredes and Mauricio Pinilla follow just outside the table.
Kohr, Germany's quickest, just off the list
No Bundesliga player makes the top twenty, and the closest is Dominik Kohr. His rate is 0.421: 107 yellows in 22,882 minutes, one every 214. Rubén Alcaraz takes twentieth place on 0.4236, so the margin between them is a few thousandths. Kohr's career has run through Leverkusen, Augsburg, Eintracht Frankfurt and, since 2020/21, Mainz, where he was booked 13 times in 2023/24.
Behind him in Germany come Maik Franz at 0.395, Carlos Zambrano and Niko Kovač at 0.392 and Jermaine Jones at 0.390. The Bundesliga simply produces fewer extreme rates, and it also has the fewest qualifiers of the four leagues, 567 against 985 in England.
Spain fills the table instead, with fourteen of the twenty rows, most of them holding midfielders and centre-backs. Deco is the most surprising Spanish entry, a playmaker in sixteenth place with 44 bookings in 9,014 minutes for Barcelona between 2004/05 and 2007/08.
For Head to Head, the useful instinct is that the totals and the rates rarely point at the same player. Pick the long-serving enforcer when the question is how many, and the short, combative career when it is how often.
The short versionBooked every 174 minutes, Jaime Mata edges Pablo García by a single minute. Cattermole, the obvious guess, drops to 0.40 once two-yellow dismissals count as reds.