‹ All posts

The settled squads: fewest players used in a season

Most clubs need 25 or more players to get through a league season. A handful have managed with barely more than a starting eleven and a bench.

By ·

At a glanceLowest 10 by players
  1. Borussia Mönchengladbach 2014/15Borussia Mönchengladbach19
  2. Leeds United 2001/02Leeds United21
  3. Werder Bremen 2001/02Werder Bremen21
  4. Bochum 2003/04Bochum21
  5. Aston Villa 2008/09Aston Villa21
  6. Bayer Leverkusen 2010/11Bayer Leverkusen21
  7. Bayern Munich 2011/12Bayern Munich21
  8. Borussia Mönchengladbach 2013/14Borussia Mönchengladbach21
  9. Bayer Leverkusen 2018/19Bayer Leverkusen21
  10. Brighton 2018/19Brighton21

Borussia Mönchengladbach got through the whole of the 2014/15 Bundesliga with 19 players. No club in the four biggest leagues has used fewer in a season since 2000/01, and only twelve others have come within two of it. Gladbach's goalkeeper Yann Sommer played all 34 games, and Mahmoud Dahoud's single appearance was the only cameo in the squad all year.

Below Gladbach the table is dominated by two countries. Twelve club-seasons sit on 21, and every one of them is German or English: Bayern Munich, Bayer Leverkusen twice, Werder Bremen, Bochum and Gladbach again from Germany, and Leeds United, Aston Villa, Brighton, Manchester City and Wolves twice from England. Spain and Italy only appear from 22 upwards, where Juventus's 2001/02 champions are Serie A's lone representative in the table.

A low number in a table like this can be a trap, because missing rows look exactly like a small squad. Every season ranked here has recorded starts that fill eleven places in every match, so the counts are real. The Premier League's 1990s are left out to keep one window across the four leagues, which matters for one famous Liverpool season discussed below.

Fewest players used by a club in one league season, big four, since 2000/01
#Club seasonPlayers
1Borussia Mönchengladbach 2014/152014/15League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games19
2Leeds United 2001/022001/02League and games: Premier League, 38 games21
3Werder Bremen 2001/022001/02League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games21
4Bochum 2003/042003/04League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games21
5Aston Villa 2008/092008/09League and games: Premier League, 38 games21
6Bayer Leverkusen 2010/112010/11League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games21
7Bayern Munich 2011/122011/12League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games21
8Borussia Mönchengladbach 2013/142013/14League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games21
9Bayer Leverkusen 2018/192018/19League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games21
10Brighton 2018/192018/19League and games: Premier League, 38 games21
11Manchester City 2018/192018/19League and games: Premier League, 38 games21
12Wolverhampton Wanderers 2018/192018/19League and games: Premier League, 38 games21
13Wolverhampton Wanderers 2019/202019/20League and games: Premier League, 38 games21
14Alavés 2001/022001/02League and games: La Liga, 38 games22
15Bayer Leverkusen 2001/022001/02League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games22
16Juventus 2001/022001/02League and games: Serie A, 34 games22
17Schalke 04 2001/022001/02League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games22
18Villarreal 2001/022001/02League and games: La Liga, 38 games22
19Hansa Rostock 2002/032002/03League and games: Bundesliga, 34 games22
20Real Sociedad 2002/032002/03League and games: La Liga, 38 games22
Seasons 2001/02 to 2019/20

Also on 22: Arsenal 2003/04, Bayer Leverkusen 2003/04, Lazio 2003/04, Manchester United 2003/04, Aston Villa 2004/05, Charlton Athletic 2004/05, Everton 2004/05, Hertha BSC 2004/05 and 30 others.

Only club-seasons whose recorded starts reach eleven in every game are ranked, so no squad here looks small because rows are missing. Thirty-eight further club-seasons also used 22 players and are left below the cut, among them Arsenal's unbeaten 2003/04.

Gladbach's 19 under Lucien Favre

The striking thing about Gladbach's 2014/15 is not just the total but how evenly it was used. Eighteen of the 19 players made at least 17 Bundesliga appearances. Max Kruse and Patrick Herrmann played 32 games each, Raffael and Tony Jantschke 31, Granit Xhaka and Christoph Kramer 30. Branimir Hrgota, the least used of the regulars, still played 17 times. Then there is Dahoud, a teenager given one outing, and nobody else.

This was a good side as well as a stable one, finishing third and qualifying for the Champions League. Lucien Favre, the coach, rarely rotated, and the previous season shows the same habit. Gladbach used 21 players in 2013/14, with Marc-André ter Stegen, Kruse, Herrmann and Raffael all playing every game.

Between the two seasons ter Stegen left for Barcelona and Sommer replaced him, and the squad actually shrank. Our records are complete for both years: the 2014/15 starts come to exactly 374, eleven for each of the 34 matches, and the minutes are within a few dozen of a full season.

The Bundesliga's habit of small squads

Seven of the thirteen squads on 21 or fewer are German. Part of the reason is arithmetic. A Bundesliga season has 34 matches rather than 38, so there are four fewer chances for injuries, suspensions and fixture pile-ups to force a change. Over a season that difference is enough to save a player or two.

The rest is selection. Bayern used 21 in 2011/12, with Thomas Müller playing all 34 games and Manuel Neuer, Holger Badstuber and Mario Gómez 33 each; Hans-Jörg Butt, the veteran reserve keeper, got a single game. Leverkusen managed 21 twice, eight years apart. The 2010/11 side was built around Arturo Vidal, Michal Kadlec and René Adler, and the 2018/19 team around Kai Havertz and Kevin Volland, who were ever-present, and Jonathan Tah and Julian Brandt, who missed one game each.

Werder Bremen in 2001/02 and Bochum in 2003/04 complete the German group. Bremen's goalkeeper Frank Rost and midfielder Frank Baumann played every match. Bochum had Rein van Duijnhoven and Tomasz Zdebel on 34 each and Dariusz Wosz, Frank Fahrenhorst and Søren Colding on 33. These were not the richest clubs in the league, which suggests that a small squad was as much a choice as a necessity.

Wolves, Manchester City and England's 21s

Six Premier League seasons reach 21, the English best in the window. Leeds United in 2001/02 had Nigel Martyn in goal for all 38 games. Aston Villa in 2008/09 had two ever-presents in Brad Friedel and Gareth Barry, with four more men on 36. Brighton in 2018/19 leaned on Glenn Murray, who played all 38.

Manchester City's 2018/19 is the one that stands out, because they won the league with it. Twenty-one players is the fewest used by a Premier League champion in our window, and Ederson played in all 38 of them. The likeliest doubt, Brahim Díaz, made no league appearance before leaving in January, so the figure holds.

Wolves did it twice in a row, which nobody else has managed in England. In 2018/19, their first season back, Conor Coady, João Moutinho, Matt Doherty and Raúl Jiménez all played 38 games. In 2019/20 six players were ever-present, including Rui Patrício and Rúben Neves, despite a Europa League campaign that started in July. For the record, Liverpool used 19 players in 1995/96, which would tie Gladbach, but that season falls before this table begins. David James, Robbie Fowler and Steve McManaman played all 38 games for them.

Why the small squad has disappeared

The 21s stop in 2019/20, with Wolves. Since then no club in the four leagues has used fewer than 22 in a season. The year 2018/19 alone produced four of the thirteen squads on 21 or fewer, and then the pattern simply vanished.

The obvious explanation is the five-substitute rule, introduced during the pandemic in 2020 and since made permanent. Five changes a game means more players get minutes as a matter of routine, and a coach who used to name the same three substitutes every week can now give a run-out to two more. A squad of 21 is far harder to keep when the bench is used so heavily.

Twenty-two is a crowded line. Besides the seven in the table, 38 more club-seasons in the window used exactly that number, among them Arsenal's unbeaten side of 2003/04 and Manchester United in the same season. Juventus won Serie A in 2001/02 with Gianluigi Buffon and David Trezeguet in all 34 games, and only Fabián O'Neill, with four appearances, played fewer than seven times.

Italy, interestingly, never reached 21 at all. Juventus's 22 in 2001/02 is Serie A's best in the table, and neither Lazio nor Roma has gone below 22 in the window: Lazio twice and Roma once have matched it. In Starting 11, these are the friendliest seasons to be asked about, because the eleven names you need are the same eleven that played almost every week.

The short version

Gladbach's 19 in 2014/15 is two clear of everyone, and nobody in the big four has used fewer than 22 since five substitutes became normal. The very small squad may be a thing of the past.