England's other crossings: Leeds and United, Villa and Birmingham
Five men have crossed the Pennines between Leeds and Manchester United in the Premier League, and seven have crossed Birmingham. The second list has not grown since 2011.
By Gareth Lloyd ·
- Rio FerdinandLeeds United 54 · Manchester United 312366
- Alan SmithLeeds United 172 · Manchester United 61233
- Dwight YorkeAston Villa 179 · Birmingham City 13192
- Liam RidgewellAston Villa 79 · Birmingham City 102181
- Emile HeskeyBirmingham City 68 · Aston Villa 92160
- Éric CantonaLeeds United 13 · Manchester United 143156
- Lee SharpeManchester United 116 · Leeds United 30146
- Daniel JamesManchester United 50 · Leeds United 55105
- Craig GardnerAston Villa 59 · Birmingham City 42101
- Kevin PhillipsAston Villa 23 · Birmingham City 3356
First clubThe other club
Leeds United and Manchester United do not share a city, a ground or even a county, and yet their feud is older and more bitter than many local derbies. In the Premier League era, from 1992/93 onwards, five players have appeared in it for both clubs: Éric Cantona, Lee Sharpe, Rio Ferdinand, Alan Smith and Daniel James. Three went from Leeds to United, two the other way, and the two moves people still bring up first are Cantona's and Ferdinand's.
Aston Villa and Birmingham City are the opposite case, two clubs from one city whose supporters live side by side. Seven men have played Premier League football for both: Dwight Yorke, Chris Sutton, Liam Ridgewell, Emile Heskey, Craig Gardner, Kevin Phillips and Curtis Davies. Every one of those crossings falls between 2004/05 and 2010/11, the run of seasons in which both clubs were in the division together.
Each row in the table gives a player's combined league appearances for his pair, Leeds and United first, then Villa and Birmingham, and lists his spells in order. Ferdinand's 366 is the biggest figure by a long way. Sutton's 18 is the smallest, and the gap between those two numbers says a lot about how differently these careers crossed over.
| # | Player | Apps for both | Spells, in order | Order of clubs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Éric Cantona1992/93–1996/97Spells, in order: Leeds United 1992/93 (13), then Manchester United 1992/93–1996/97 (143) | 156 | Leeds United 1992/93 (13), then Manchester United 1992/93–1996/97 (143) | Leeds United, Manchester United |
| 2 | Lee Sharpe1992/93–1998/99Spells, in order: Manchester United 1992/93–1995/96 (116), then Leeds United 1996/97–1998/99 (30) | 146 | Manchester United 1992/93–1995/96 (116), then Leeds United 1996/97–1998/99 (30) | Manchester United, Leeds United |
| 3 | Rio Ferdinand2000/01–2013/14Spells, in order: Leeds United 2000/01–2001/02 (54), then Manchester United 2002/03–2013/14 (312) | 366 | Leeds United 2000/01–2001/02 (54), then Manchester United 2002/03–2013/14 (312) | Leeds United, Manchester United |
| 4 | Alan Smith1998/99–2006/07Spells, in order: Leeds United 1998/99–2003/04 (172), then Manchester United 2004/05–2006/07 (61) | 233 | Leeds United 1998/99–2003/04 (172), then Manchester United 2004/05–2006/07 (61) | Leeds United, Manchester United |
| 5 | Daniel James2019/20–2025/26Spells, in order: Manchester United 2019/20–2021/22 (50), then Leeds United 2021/22–2025/26 (55) | 105 | Manchester United 2019/20–2021/22 (50), then Leeds United 2021/22–2025/26 (55) | Manchester United, Leeds United |
| 6 | Dwight Yorke1992/93–2004/05Spells, in order: Aston Villa 1992/93–1998/99 (179), then Birmingham City 2004/05 (13) | 192 | Aston Villa 1992/93–1998/99 (179), then Birmingham City 2004/05 (13) | Aston Villa, Birmingham City |
| 7 | Chris Sutton2005/06–2006/07Spells, in order: Birmingham City 2005/06 (10), then Aston Villa 2006/07 (8) | 18 | Birmingham City 2005/06 (10), then Aston Villa 2006/07 (8) | Birmingham City, Aston Villa |
| 8 | Liam Ridgewell2003/04–2010/11Spells, in order: Aston Villa 2003/04–2006/07 (79), then Birmingham City 2007/08–2010/11 (102) | 181 | Aston Villa 2003/04–2006/07 (79), then Birmingham City 2007/08–2010/11 (102) | Aston Villa, Birmingham City |
| 9 | Emile Heskey2004/05–2011/12Spells, in order: Birmingham City 2004/05–2005/06 (68), then Aston Villa 2008/09–2011/12 (92) | 160 | Birmingham City 2004/05–2005/06 (68), then Aston Villa 2008/09–2011/12 (92) | Birmingham City, Aston Villa |
| 10 | Craig Gardner2005/06–2010/11Spells, in order: Aston Villa 2005/06–2009/10 (59), then Birmingham City 2009/10–2010/11 (42) | 101 | Aston Villa 2005/06–2009/10 (59), then Birmingham City 2009/10–2010/11 (42) | Aston Villa, Birmingham City |
| 11 | Kevin Phillips2005/06–2010/11Spells, in order: Aston Villa 2005/06 (23), then Birmingham City 2009/10–2010/11 (33) | 56 | Aston Villa 2005/06 (23), then Birmingham City 2009/10–2010/11 (33) | Aston Villa, Birmingham City |
| 12 | Curtis Davies2007/08–2010/11Spells, in order: Aston Villa 2007/08–2009/10 (49), then Birmingham City 2010/11 (6) | 55 | Aston Villa 2007/08–2009/10 (49), then Birmingham City 2010/11 (6) | Aston Villa, Birmingham City |
| Seasons 1992/93 to 2025/26 | ||||
The first five rows are the Leeds and Manchester United pair, the last seven the Villa and Birmingham pair, each in the order the players reached their second club. Only Premier League games count, so men whose games for one of the clubs came in a lower division are not listed.
Cantona and Ferdinand, the two sales Leeds regret
Cantona's Leeds career in the Premier League was thirteen games long. He scored six times in them during the autumn of 1992 and then, before that first season was out, he was a Manchester United player. He added 22 games and nine goals for his new club in 1992/93. Over five seasons at Old Trafford he played 143 league games and scored 64 goals, with 18 of them coming in 1993/94, and 1996/97 was his last season. He is one of three men in the table to appear for both clubs of a pair in a single season.
Ferdinand's route was slower and far more expensive. He came through at West Ham, played 12 league games for them in 2000/01 and joined Leeds partway through the same campaign, finishing it with 23 appearances and two goals for his new club. He added 31 more the following season, which brought his Leeds total to 54, and then left for Manchester United in 2002.
What followed was a twelve-season stay. Ferdinand played 312 Premier League games for United between 2002/03 and 2013/14, scoring seven times, with a high of 37 appearances in 2005/06. His 366 games for the two clubs combined is the largest figure in either half of the table, and almost all of it was played in red. He finished with 11 games for Queens Park Rangers in 2014/15.
Alan Smith, Sharpe and James
This is the Alan Smith born in 1980 who came through the Leeds academy, not the Arsenal striker of the late 1980s and early 1990s. He made his Premier League debut in 1998/99 and stayed six seasons, playing 172 league games and scoring 38 goals, eleven of them in 2000/01. When Leeds went down in 2004 he joined Manchester United, a move made sharper by how closely he had been identified with Elland Road.
His United spell lasted three seasons: 31 games and six goals in 2004/05, then 21 and one, then nine without a goal. That came to 61 appearances. He later played 52 Premier League games for Newcastle without scoring, so the goals in his career belong almost entirely to Leeds.
Two players crossed in the opposite direction. Lee Sharpe played 116 league games for United in the first four Premier League seasons, scoring 17, and moved to Leeds for 1996/97, where he made 26 appearances and scored five. He added only four more, in 1998/99, before moving on to Bradford City.
Daniel James is the most recent name. He played 50 games for United across three seasons, the last two of them in August 2021, and joined Leeds that month. Thirty-two games and four goals followed in 2021/22. After a loan year spent mostly at Fulham and a spell outside the top flight, he was back in Leeds colours in 2025/26 for another 19, taking his Leeds total to 55.
Yorke, Heskey and the Second City years
Dwight Yorke is the reason the Villa and Birmingham half of the table starts so high. He played 179 Premier League games for Villa from 1992/93, with 17 goals in each of 1995/96 and 1996/97 and 60 in all, before his move to Manchester United in 1998. After United and Blackburn he joined Birmingham in 2004/05 and played 13 games for them, scoring twice, in a season that also included four games back at Blackburn.
Emile Heskey went the other way and needed a stop in between. He spent two seasons at Birmingham from 2004/05, playing 34 games in each and scoring 14 goals, then three seasons at Wigan. Villa signed him during 2008/09, and his 92 games for them over four seasons brought nine goals, which leaves him with 160 for the pair.
The other five moves were quieter. Liam Ridgewell went straight from Villa, where he played 79 games, to Birmingham in 2007, and he made 102 appearances there. Craig Gardner did it in the middle of 2009/10, playing once for Villa and 13 times for Birmingham that season. Kevin Phillips played 23 games for Villa in 2005/06 and reached Birmingham by way of West Bromwich Albion. Curtis Davies had six games on loan at Birmingham in 2010/11 after 49 for Villa. Chris Sutton played ten games for Birmingham in 2005/06 and eight for Villa the season after, and scored once for each.
Distance, direction and a closed window
The two lists are built very differently. The Leeds and United crossings are spread across almost three decades, from Cantona in 1992 to James in 2021, and they include the two most famous names on either list. The Villa and Birmingham crossings are bunched into seven seasons, and none of them involved a player at his peak. Yorke was in his thirties when he reached Birmingham, Sutton was close to retiring, and Davies was a loan signing.
That bunching follows the league table. Birmingham were relegated in 2011 and have not been back in the Premier League since, so no new name has been possible for well over a decade. The Leeds pairing has had long gaps for the same reason, with Leeds out of the division for years after 2004, and James's two spells either side of their Championship years show how a crossing can survive one.
Direction tells a story too. Five of the seven Second City crossers started at Villa and moved on to Birmingham. Three of the five Pennine crossers started at Leeds, and the two biggest moves both went to United. Leeds lost Ferdinand and an academy graduate in Smith to the same neighbour, and Birmingham mostly took players Villa had finished with.
For Played for All, the list worth learning is the Villa and Birmingham one, because its seven names all come from one compact period and three of them, Yorke, Heskey and Phillips, are better known for other clubs entirely.
The short versionFerdinand's 366 games make Leeds and United the heavier crossing. Villa and Birmingham have more names, all of them between 2004 and 2011, and the route has been shut since Birmingham went down.