‹ All posts

Old Firm, Rome and the Ruhr: the rarest crossings

Three derbies, eleven players, and in two of the three cities almost all of the traffic has run in a single direction.

By ·

At a glanceGames for each club
  1. Kenny MillerRangers 29 · Celtic 33 · Rangers 136198
  2. PedroRoma 27 · Lazio 160187
  3. Aleksandar KolarovLazio 82 · Roma 100182
  4. Christoph MetzelderBorussia Dortmund 125 · Schalke 04 52177
  5. Sebastiano SivigliaRoma 5 · Lazio 157162
  6. Alessio RomagnoliRoma 13 · Lazio 127140
  7. Felipe SantanaBorussia Dortmund 95 · Schalke 04 24119
  8. Luca PellegriniRoma 4 · Lazio 7276
  9. Kevin-Prince BoatengBorussia Dortmund 10 · Schalke 04 4656
  10. Steven PressleyRangers 31 · Celtic 1950

First clubThe other club

Some derbies are hard to cross because the clubs rarely sell to each other. Others are hard to cross because the supporters would never forgive the player. Glasgow, Rome and the Ruhr are usually put in the second group, and the records bear the reputation out. Since 1992/93 only three men have played Scottish top-flight games for both Celtic and Rangers. Since 2000/01 five have played Serie A games for Roma and Lazio, and three have played Bundesliga games for Borussia Dortmund and Schalke 04.

That is eleven crossings across three cities, and the table lists all of them, derby by derby, with each spell and the games played in it. The combined figures run from 17, for a goalkeeper who was mostly a reserve at both Old Firm clubs, to 198 for Kenny Miller, the one man in the table who crossed his city twice.

Direction matters as much as numbers here. All three Old Firm crossings started at Rangers. All three Ruhr crossings started at Dortmund. In Rome, four of the five went from Roma to Lazio, and only Aleksandar Kolarov went the other way. Several familiar names, Andreas Möller and Siniša Mihajlović among them, are missing because one half of their crossing came before the window opened.

League players with games for both Celtic and Rangers, Roma and Lazio, or Dortmund and Schalke
#PlayerApps for both
1Kenny Miller2000/01–2017/18Derby, then spells in order: Old Firm: Rangers 2000/01–2001/02 (29), then Celtic 2006/07–2007/08 (33), then Rangers 2008/09–2017/18 (136)198
2Mark Brown1999/00–2008/09Derby, then spells in order: Old Firm: Rangers 1999/00–2000/01 (4), then Celtic 2006/07–2008/09 (13)17
3Steven Pressley1992/93–2007/08Derby, then spells in order: Old Firm: Rangers 1992/93–1994/95 (31), then Celtic 2006/07–2007/08 (19)50
4Sebastiano Siviglia2001/02–2009/10Derby, then spells in order: Rome: Roma 2001/02 (5), then Lazio 2004/05–2009/10 (157)162
5Aleksandar Kolarov2007/08–2019/20Derby, then spells in order: Rome: Lazio 2007/08–2009/10 (82), then Roma 2017/18–2019/20 (100)182
6Pedro2020/21–2025/26Derby, then spells in order: Rome: Roma 2020/21 (27), then Lazio 2021/22–2025/26 (160)187
7Alessio Romagnoli2012/13–2025/26Derby, then spells in order: Rome: Roma 2012/13–2013/14 (13), then Lazio 2022/23–2025/26 (127)140
8Luca Pellegrini2018/19–2025/26Derby, then spells in order: Rome: Roma 2018/19 (4), then Lazio 2022/23–2025/26 (72)76
9Christoph Metzelder2000/01–2012/13Derby, then spells in order: Ruhr: Borussia Dortmund 2000/01–2006/07 (125), then Schalke 04 2010/11–2012/13 (52)177
10Felipe Santana2008/09–2014/15Derby, then spells in order: Ruhr: Borussia Dortmund 2008/09–2012/13 (95), then Schalke 04 2013/14–2014/15 (24)119
11Kevin-Prince Boateng2008/09–2014/15Derby, then spells in order: Ruhr: Borussia Dortmund 2008/09 (10), then Schalke 04 2013/14–2014/15 (46)56
Seasons 1992/93 in Britain, 2000/01 elsewhere to 2025/26

Scottish games count from 1992/93 and the Italian and German ones from 2000/01, and only top-flight league games are included. A gap spent elsewhere is folded into one spell, so Miller's last Rangers entry covers two separate stays.

Kenny Miller goes there and back

Miller came to Rangers from Hibernian and played 26 Scottish Premier League games for them in 2000/01, scoring eight. He made only three more appearances the following season, and after 2001/02 he had no Scottish top-flight game at all until 2006/07. When he came back, it was in a Celtic shirt. He played 31 times and scored four in that first season, then two more games, both with a goal, at the start of 2007/08.

That would have been enough to put him in the table. What makes him unique is the next step. In 2008/09 he was back at Rangers, scoring ten in 30 games, then 18 in 33 the season after and 18 in only 18 games in 2010/11. He left again, and returned for a third Rangers stay that brought 37 top-flight games in 2016/17 and 18 more in 2017/18. His Rangers games in the Championship in 2014/15 and 2015/16 were not top-flight football and are not counted.

Add it up and Miller has 165 league games for Rangers and 33 for Celtic. Every outside list of Old Firm crossings treats him as the only player of the post-war era to have made the move twice. Mo Johnston and Alfie Conn, the two names usually mentioned alongside him, played their games for both clubs before 1992/93.

Pressley, Brown and Celtic's 2006/07 arrivals

The other two Old Firm crossings arrived at Celtic in the same season as Miller. Steven Pressley started at Rangers as a teenager, with 31 games across 1992/93 to 1994/95, and then spent most of his career elsewhere: two seasons at Dundee United and eight full seasons at Hearts from 1998/99. In 2006/07 he played 13 games for Hearts and 14 for Celtic, so the move came midway through the campaign. He added five more Celtic games in 2007/08, for 19 in all.

Mark Brown's path ran through even more clubs. A goalkeeper, he played one game for Rangers in 1999/00 and three in 2000/01, then moved on to Motherwell and, from 2004/05, Inverness Caledonian Thistle. He split 2006/07 between Inverness, where he made 23 appearances, and Celtic, where he made one. Eight more Celtic games followed in 2007/08 and four in 2008/09.

Brown's 17 games for the pair are the fewest of the eleven players in the table, and his four for Rangers match Luca Pellegrini's four for Roma as the shortest spell at either end. Twelve years separate Pressley's last Rangers game from his first for Celtic, which is about as cold a crossing as the table contains.

Kolarov against the Roman current

Rome has the busiest of the three lists, and its five names split cleanly. Sebastiano Siviglia played five games for Roma in 2001/02 and, after stops at Atalanta, Parma and Lecce, 157 for Lazio between 2004/05 and 2009/10. Alessio Romagnoli and Luca Pellegrini both came through at Roma, played 13 and four games there, and made their names elsewhere first. Romagnoli spent seven seasons at Milan before joining Lazio for 2022/23, and Pellegrini passed through Cagliari, Genoa and Juventus on the way.

Pedro is the only one of the five to go straight across. After one season and 27 games for Roma in 2020/21 he joined Lazio on a free in August 2021, a move reports described as the first direct crossing of the city in decades. He has since played 160 league games for Lazio and scored 29, ten of them in 2024/25.

Kolarov is the exception in the other sense. He began at Lazio, with 82 games from 2007/08 to 2009/10, and then spent seven Premier League seasons at Manchester City. When he returned to Italy it was with Roma, for whom he played 100 times and scored 17 goals, eight of them in 2018/19. He is the only player in the window to have gone from Lazio to Roma.

Every Ruhr crossing started at Dortmund

The German list is the most one-sided of the three. Christoph Metzelder played his Bundesliga football for Dortmund between 2000/01 and 2006/07, spent time at Real Madrid, and returned to the Bundesliga with Schalke for 52 games between 2010/11 and 2012/13. Kevin-Prince Boateng's Dortmund spell was a loan of ten games in 2008/09, and he played 46 for Schalke in 2013/14 and 2014/15. Felipe Santana alone made the move without a stop in between: 95 games for Dortmund across five seasons, then 24 for Schalke from 2013/14.

Nobody has gone from Schalke to Dortmund inside the window. The names that did, Jens Lehmann the best known, made the move in the 1990s. Möller's crossing followed the same direction as the three in the table, Dortmund to Schalke, but his Dortmund games came before 2000/01, so he is outside the count. In Rome the same applies to Mihajlović, Diego Fuser, Roberto Muzzi and Francesco Colonnese.

Put the three cities side by side and the rates are close. Glasgow has three crossings in 34 Scottish seasons, the Ruhr three in 26 Bundesliga seasons, and Rome five in 26 Serie A seasons. Glasgow's three all reached Celtic in a single season and nobody has crossed there since Miller's return in 2008/09. The Ruhr has had no crossing since 2013/14, while Rome's two most recent came in 2022/23. For Played for All, these three pairings have answer lists short enough to learn completely, and the direction of each move is usually the clue that settles a question.

The short version

Eleven players have crossed Glasgow, Rome or the Ruhr in our windows. Kenny Miller is the only one to do it twice, and Kolarov is the only one to move against his city's usual direction.