Newcastle and Sunderland: 12 who played for both
Twelve players, six crossings in each direction, and a clean break in the middle: before 2014 the traffic went to Sunderland, and since then it has all gone to Newcastle.
By Gareth Lloyd · · Updated
- Jack ColbackSunderland 115 · Newcastle United 64179
- Titus BrambleNewcastle United 105 · Sunderland 47152
- Javier ManquilloSunderland 20 · Newcastle United 96116
- DeAndre YedlinSunderland 23 · Newcastle United 85108
- Paul BracewellNewcastle United 48 · Sunderland 3886
- Andy ColeNewcastle United 58 · Sunderland 765
- Michael ChopraNewcastle United 21 · Sunderland 3960
- Steven CaldwellNewcastle United 28 · Sunderland 2452
- Ki Sung-yuengSunderland 27 · Newcastle United 2148
- Danny RoseSunderland 27 · Newcastle United 1138
First clubThe other club
Since 1992, twelve footballers have pulled on both the black and white of Newcastle United and the red and white of Sunderland in Premier League matches. The list starts with Paul Bracewell, who left Newcastle after 1994/95 and played 38 games for Sunderland in 1996/97, and it ends, for now, with Danny Rose, whose Newcastle loan in 2019/20 is the latest second spell. In between are Andy Cole, Louis Saha, Titus Bramble and Jack Colback, the only player who walked straight from one club to the other.
Split by direction, the twelve divide exactly in half. Bracewell, Steven Caldwell, Cole, Michael Chopra, Bramble and Saha played for Newcastle first. Michael Bridges, Colback, DeAndre Yedlin, Javier Manquillo, Ki Sung-yueng and Rose played for Sunderland first. The timing is the striking part. Up to 2012/13, every crossing except Bridges' went from Newcastle to Sunderland. Every one since Colback's in 2014 has gone the other way.
Each row below totals a player's league appearances across the pair and sets out his spells as they happened. Colback's 179 lead it. Saha's 22, eleven for each club fourteen seasons apart, are the fewest.
| # | Player | Apps for both | Spells, in order | Order of clubs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Paul Bracewell1993/94–1996/97Spells, in order: Newcastle United 1993/94–1994/95 (48), then Sunderland 1996/97 (38) | 86 | Newcastle United 1993/94–1994/95 (48), then Sunderland 1996/97 (38) | Newcastle United, Sunderland |
| 2 | Michael Bridges1996/97–2003/04Spells, in order: Sunderland 1996/97 (25), then Newcastle United 2003/04 (6) | 31 | Sunderland 1996/97 (25), then Newcastle United 2003/04 (6) | Sunderland, Newcastle United |
| 3 | Steven Caldwell2000/01–2005/06Spells, in order: Newcastle United 2000/01–2003/04 (28), then Sunderland 2005/06 (24) | 52 | Newcastle United 2000/01–2003/04 (28), then Sunderland 2005/06 (24) | Newcastle United, Sunderland |
| 4 | Andy Cole1993/94–2007/08Spells, in order: Newcastle United 1993/94–1994/95 (58), then Sunderland 2007/08 (7) | 65 | Newcastle United 1993/94–1994/95 (58), then Sunderland 2007/08 (7) | Newcastle United, Sunderland |
| 5 | Michael Chopra2002/03–2008/09Spells, in order: Newcastle United 2002/03–2005/06 (21), then Sunderland 2007/08–2008/09 (39) | 60 | Newcastle United 2002/03–2005/06 (21), then Sunderland 2007/08–2008/09 (39) | Newcastle United, Sunderland |
| 6 | Titus Bramble2002/03–2012/13Spells, in order: Newcastle United 2002/03–2006/07 (105), then Sunderland 2010/11–2012/13 (47) | 152 | Newcastle United 2002/03–2006/07 (105), then Sunderland 2010/11–2012/13 (47) | Newcastle United, Sunderland |
| 7 | Louis Saha1998/99–2012/13Spells, in order: Newcastle United 1998/99 (11), then Sunderland 2012/13 (11) | 22 | Newcastle United 1998/99 (11), then Sunderland 2012/13 (11) | Newcastle United, Sunderland |
| 8 | Jack Colback2009/10–2015/16Spells, in order: Sunderland 2009/10–2013/14 (115), then Newcastle United 2014/15–2015/16 (64) | 179 | Sunderland 2009/10–2013/14 (115), then Newcastle United 2014/15–2015/16 (64) | Sunderland, Newcastle United |
| 9 | DeAndre Yedlin2015/16–2020/21Spells, in order: Sunderland 2015/16 (23), then Newcastle United 2017/18–2020/21 (85) | 108 | Sunderland 2015/16 (23), then Newcastle United 2017/18–2020/21 (85) | Sunderland, Newcastle United |
| 10 | Javier Manquillo2016/17–2022/23Spells, in order: Sunderland 2016/17 (20), then Newcastle United 2017/18–2022/23 (96) | 116 | Sunderland 2016/17 (20), then Newcastle United 2017/18–2022/23 (96) | Sunderland, Newcastle United |
| 11 | Ki Sung-yueng2013/14–2019/20Spells, in order: Sunderland 2013/14 (27), then Newcastle United 2018/19–2019/20 (21) | 48 | Sunderland 2013/14 (27), then Newcastle United 2018/19–2019/20 (21) | Sunderland, Newcastle United |
| 12 | Danny Rose2012/13–2019/20Spells, in order: Sunderland 2012/13 (27), then Newcastle United 2019/20 (11) | 38 | Sunderland 2012/13 (27), then Newcastle United 2019/20 (11) | Sunderland, Newcastle United |
| Seasons 1993/94 to 2022/23 | ||||
Rows run in the order the players first appeared for their second club, and the value is Premier League games only. Second-tier seasons at either club are outside the count, which is why Lee Clark, a Sunderland player only in the second tier, is absent.
Cole and Saha, forwards who went south
Andy Cole's Newcastle numbers are the best in the table by any measure. He scored 34 Premier League goals in 40 games in 1993/94 and nine more in 18 games the following season before his move to Manchester United, 43 in 58 in all. His Sunderland spell came thirteen seasons later, at the end of a career that had taken him through Blackburn, Fulham, Manchester City and Portsmouth, and it lasted seven games in 2007/08 without a goal. It is the shortest spell any of the twelve had at either club.
Saha's route was similar in outline. He arrived at Newcastle on loan in 1998/99, played 11 games and scored once, and then spent the next decade and more at Fulham, Manchester United, Everton and Tottenham. Sunderland was his last Premier League club, 11 games in 2012/13, again without scoring.
Michael Chopra is the striker who reversed the pattern. He managed 21 league games and one goal for Newcastle between 2002/03 and 2005/06. At Sunderland he scored six in 33 games in 2007/08 and added two more the season after, eight in 39, the most anyone in the table scored for Sunderland.
Bramble, Caldwell and the defenders
Titus Bramble has the second-highest combined total, 152. He joined Newcastle from Ipswich and played 105 Premier League games in five seasons, scoring three, then spent three seasons at Wigan before moving to Sunderland, where he added 47 more between 2010/11 and 2012/13. Of the Newcastle-first group, nobody played more for the second club.
Steven Caldwell's spell at Newcastle was spread thin: 28 games between 2000/01 and 2003/04, with a stint at Leeds during the last of those seasons. He went to Sunderland for 2005/06 and played 24 games in one season, nearly as many as in his whole Newcastle career.
The later defenders form a different group. Yedlin, Manquillo and Rose all played for Sunderland on loan first, Yedlin and Rose from Tottenham and Manquillo from Atlético Madrid, before turning up at Newcastle. Manquillo's 96 Newcastle games over six seasons are the longest second spell of anyone in the table, and Yedlin's 85 are next. Rose's Newcastle loan was much shorter: 11 games in 2019/20, a season he also played 12 times for Tottenham.
Colback walks across
Jack Colback is the one player who made the move directly, at the end of his Sunderland contract in 2014, with no club in between. He had started his Premier League career at Sunderland and played 115 Premier League games for them across five seasons, 35 in each of 2011/12 and 2012/13 and 33 in 2013/14, scoring four. He then played 64 for Newcastle in two seasons and scored five, which makes him the only one of the twelve with at least four goals for both clubs.
Moves of this kind are the ones supporters hold onto, because a free transfer gives the selling club nothing and the player chose the destination himself. Newcastle's own announcement made a point of the history, calling him the eighth player to appear for both clubs in the Premier League era, and our count agrees: Bracewell, Bridges, Caldwell, Cole, Chopra, Bramble and Saha were the seven before him.
Colback's move also marks the turning point. He was the first Sunderland-to-Newcastle crossing since Bridges, and every one of the four players who followed him went the same way.
Why the traffic turned towards Newcastle
The early crossings mostly took players Newcastle had finished with. Bracewell, Cole, Caldwell, Chopra, Bramble and Saha all reached Sunderland after their Newcastle time was over, several of them years later and by way of other clubs.
After 2014 the roles reversed. Yedlin, Manquillo, Ki and Rose had each spent a season at Sunderland on loan from another club, and Newcastle later picked them up when they were available. Ki's route was the longest: a loan season at Sunderland in 2013/14, four more years at Swansea, and then 21 Newcastle games in 2018/19 and 2019/20. None of the four stayed at Sunderland beyond that one loan season. Yedlin and Manquillo went on to play far more for Newcastle, 85 and 96 games against 23 and 20, while Ki and Rose had shorter Newcastle spells than Sunderland ones. The second wave, in other words, was made of players Sunderland had only ever borrowed.
That second wave also came to a stop. No player has crossed since Rose's loan ended in 2020. Sunderland's return to the Premier League in 2025/26 reopened the route, but the table has no crossing from that first season back.
Played for All puzzles on this pairing can be learned as two groups of six. If a puzzle asks for a Sunderland-first player, the likely answers are the full-backs who came on loan. If it asks for a Newcastle-first striker, Cole, Saha and Chopra are the names to try.
The short versionTwelve players have crossed the Tyne–Wear divide in the Premier League, six each way. Before 2014 they went to Sunderland; since Jack Colback, they have all gone to Newcastle.